Homemade Nutella

Last week Twitter was on fire about the homemade Nutella recipe published by the LATimes. Well, at least it was among the people I follow!

Robert Gauthier, Los Angeles Times

Robert Gauthier, Los Angeles Times

Naturally, I was smitten- Nutella being one thing I really don’t like in the American market version. So, I went about gathering all the ingredients, and started mixing! However  I found out pretty quick that the LA Times recipe was not going to work out for me- I like my companatico sweet, I was not willing to buy a bottle of hazelnut oil for $24, and I don’t own a *real* food processor (only a hand blender with its food-processing mini-tool), so I started playing with the recipe right away. This is what I ended up with.

1 cup of raw hazelnuts
4 tablespoon unsweetened cocoa powder
1 cup powdered sugar
1/4 teaspoon vanilla
1 tablespoons roasted walnut oil (but I might take it off altogether)
2 tablespoon whole milk, more as needed

Homemade Nutella and Almost All Ingredients

I started by toasting the hazelnuts for about 10 minutes in a 375 degree oven. I put them on a cookie sheet covered in aluminum foil, as they get messy when they roast. Them I let them cool down for about five minutes, but not too long or the peels won’t come off. Once they cool, I rubbed the hazelnuts in my hands to take off as much of the skin as possible. I then put them in the small food-processing attachment of my hand blender. I miked it for about 5 minutes, scooping the mixture from the sides every minute or so to make sure it was well blended. The original recipe says it should get to a smooth butter, but it didn’t happen for me!- the texture was still a bit rough. Once you feel it won’t get any smoother, add the cocoa, the sugar, the oil, and the vanilla. Mix again- if you have the same issues I have had, the added powdery stuff didn’t blend in too well, and when it did my food processor started to sound as it might explode. That’s when I decided to add just a drop of milk. It worked wonders! I added a tablespoon initially, and when the blender gave me clear indication it did not like to go any further I took everything off in a bowl. I continued adding milk just a tablespoon at the time while I mixed with a spoon till I reached the texture I wanted- creamy and spreadable! The result? Delightful! It even passed the picky Italian eaters test (you know who you are!). And I made another batch for the weekend’s breakfast!

Homemade Nutella: The Final Product

14 Responses to “Homemade Nutella”

  1. Oh my goodness, I want some!

  2. Mmm! I’m going to try and make with a mortar and pestle. It turns most nuts into a smooth butter.

  3. YES!!!!!!!!!! Thank you!!!! This is awesome, and I love the improvements :)

  4. Awesome recipe and has to beat any Americanized store version.

  5. Thanks so much. I’m going to try it!

  6. I miss European Nutella. Will definitely try this recipe!

  7. How much “homemade Nutella” do you get with those ingredient amounts?

  8. Grazie to you all for your kind words!
    Anton, I got a bit more than a cup, just enough to fill a Bonne Maman marmalade jar…

  9. I did an analysis on this at nutritiondata.com and the calorie count is 128 per ounce. Not bad at all! It’s a go.
    Thanks

  10. Thanks Renee- good to know!

  11. You made me want to have some right now! lol.
    Is there really american nutella and european nutella? No wonder i wanst too crazy about the bottle that i bought here. sigh..

  12. This Nutella is phenomenal!!!!
    The Picky Italian Taster

  13. Ohmigosh! I love that you have a recipe for Nutella. The bottled version has transfats so I never buy it. This would be great with crepes! I also only own a hand blender. It’s versatile enough.

  14. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!
    I TRIED IT AND IT’S SOOOO TASTYY AND EASY TO MAKE

Leave a Reply